Biostars

What’s the Answer? (genomics guidance for the general public)

This week’s highlighted discussion at Biostars was one that I opened. I’ve been thinking a lot about this, because I’m seeing it come up in a number of different ways. There are folks who are googling and finding genomics nerds in a variety of places. Some of the communities will be more welcoming than others. But I think it’s in our best interest to be helpful to families with data, and not come off too harsh because it’s not exactly how our forum works….


Biostars is a site for asking, answering and discussing bioinformatics questions and issues. We are members of the Biostars_logo community and find it very useful. Often questions and answers arise at Biostars that are germane to our readers (end users of genomics resources). Thursdays we will be highlighting one of those items or discussions here in this thread. You can ask questions in this thread, or you can always join in at Biostars.


Forum: For the general public seeking advice from this community

Hello folks–

Yesterday I saw a thread posted by a member of the general public, looking for advice for their child’s medical issues. This thread has been deleted (I think), but I was able to read some of the commentary before it disappeared.

The community had some concerns about private medical information being revealed. And some concerns about seeking advice from strangers on the internet instead of qualified practitioners in real life. These are valid issues.

However, my point is more general. This may become increasingly an issue here as more people have (or hear about) sequence information, and want some advice for it. I think it is wise for this community to stay away from diagnosis. But I think we could offer these folks some guidance to appropriate resources.

Please have some compassion for the desperation that the parents of kids with undiagnosed conditions face. And keep in mind that their thresholds for privacy are not the same as everyone else, possibly. And understand that they are hearing stories about how familes connected with researchers who could help them from random internet forums. The most recent one I saw was this: Answers.

But other stories like this are widely read: How Genome Sequencing Creates Communities Around Rare Disorders.

Could we possibly have a place to point these families, like a thread that we can sticky or something? Where we can offer them connections to the Rare Disease sequencing projects, or genetic counseling resources, non-wonky information sources like Genetics Home Reference, or something? The international group here probably could collect a good set of pointers for people around the world.

I guess I’m asking for a constructive place for some guidance for families, and a policy about how to deal with those kinds of threads.

Open for discussion.

Has any of the genomics nerd discussion communities developed a policy on this? Should we reach out to genetic counselors, maybe? We may also need legal advice. Anyone seen other places take this on? Please add your thoughts over at Biostars.